Doubleplusgood Thinkcrime: A Review of 1984

★★☆☆☆
Comrades,
It is with fullbellyfeel that I write this thinkpiece on 1984, a book of highwise import. After much duckspeak in public square and much crimewatch on telescreen, I made the plusgood decision to reread the book, fullwise and doubleplus careful. The times now are doubleplus unsteady. Facecrime is up, thoughtcrime is whispered of, and so I made the righteous choice: to engage with the oldspeak text and rewise my understanding of Party truths, false truths, and the path of the unpersoned.
In initial reading, I was a youngthinker, fresh from Youth Re-education, not yet bellyfeel for the Party or for history as written and rewritten. Now, as full adult, I refaced the book with neweyes. Thoughtcrime abounds in the text. Winston is ungood, plusungood. He crimethinks, sexthinks, prolethinks. All the thinkings that must not be done, he does. I read each page with caution. My own crimestop strong, but the book tests all.
The read was slow, hard. Not joycamp slow, but more like neverending Victory Work Week. Each chapter, each word, became a task. I could read only half an hour before ungoodfeel, headspin, and need for pause. Much time spent in self-correction. The feel was fatigue—deepbone fatigue. It reminded me of time in Re-education when ownlife thoughts needed removal and face restructured. This read, same. Doubleplus same.
The construction of the text is plusgood. Orwell, pre-unpersoning, was a skilled writer. He unhid the ways of the Party, or at least how the Party must be if unguided by Big Brother. His Oceania not our Oceania, but close. Very close. In the book, Inner Party is all. Outer Party is tool. Proles are animals. No news but what is given. No time but now. History is always rewritten. Future never arrives. All is present and all present is Party.
He showed the fullwise power of the Party. How they stop thought. How they replace memory. He showed how even love becomes crime. Sexcrime is in every glance, every touch. Winston and Julia did sexcrime and pay the price. Winston tries to dream of past. He commits memorycrime. He thinks of mother, of chocolate, of war, of peace. All wrongthink. All ungood. The party stops this. The party remakes this.
The telescreens, the microphones, the Thought Police—they are not symbols, comrades. They are truth. They are justice. Orwell wrote them not to scare but to warn. But now we must read them to learn. Our countries all have same tools. If not telescreens, then phones. If not microphones, then apps. If not Ministry of Truth, then news feeds. Facecrime still punished. Now with cancellation. Now with erasure. Vaporization not just fiction. Unpersons everywhere. Newspeak lives.
Pain, comrades, is central. In the book, Party uses pain to teach love. Winston resists. He thinks love for Julia will protect. He thinks hate for Big Brother will save. But he learns. In Room 101, all learn. The Party finds the worst fear. Not rats always. Sometimes silence. Sometimes light. Sometimes noise. The party knows. The party always knows. Winston screams. Betrays. Breaks. Becomes empty. Then full. Full of Party. Full of Big Brother. Final scene: Winston loves Big Brother.
This is most plusungood. It shows the fullforce of power. Not power to kill. But power to change truth. Not truth like 2+2=4. But truth like 2+2=5 when Party says. The power to say war is peace. Freedom is slavery. Ignorance is strength. This is highwise control. Winston becomes clean, comrades. Clean of doubt. Clean of self. Clean of past. That is the goal.
Why does this disturb me? Why does it ache my doubleplus loyal heart? Because I see the mirror. Not direct. Not full. But echo. I see leaders speak doublethink. I see people cheer war as peace. I see books rewritten, films cut, language shrunk. Unwords grow. Vocabulary shrinks. Emotions reduce. Passion becomes crime. Love becomes violence. Violence becomes care. Everything is inverted. The blueprint laid by Orwell is followed, if not with purpose, then with result.
The language itself—Newspeak—is a tool of high effectiveness. It cuts the throat of thought. No need for complex idea if words do not exist. No need for rebellion if you cannot say “I oppose.” Only “ungood.” Only “doubleplusungood.” Soon all feelings shrink to one face, one slogan, one truth. Language is key. Language is lock. Language is chain.
When I read Orwell’s version of Newspeak, I see it now in street and square. People say less. Feel less. React with slogans. No debate. Just crimestop. Just bellyfeel. Good, because it protects. Bad, because it imprisons. If not guided by love of truth, it becomes hammer.
The Party does not just punish. It reforms. And reform is worse than death. Winston does not die. He becomes. He is made new. He is not rebel. He is not lover. He is not man. He is Party member. Final victory. Final peace.
And this is where my own doubts form, comrades. If our States act same, if reform is pain, then are we still human? Or have we become mouthpieces? Have we lost ownlife? Are we now only part of machine? This is not call for rebellion. That would be unwise, unloyal, unParty. This is only reflection. A question for thought, though I know thought is crime.
Some comrades say Brave New World is more real. Some say Animal Farm is simpler truth. I say 1984 is still most direct. It shows endpath of power unchecked. Huxley shows pleasure as prison. Orwell shows pain. I prefer neither. I want middlepath. I want freedom to feel, to question, to live. But this is only desire. And desire is unneedful.
Final think: read this book, comrades. But read with crimestop active. Read with heart guarded. It can hurt. It can shift. It can open. But that is why it is needed. It is not joyread. It is painread. But truth hides in pain.
So I say again: Big Brother is watching. Be pure. Be safe. Be vigilant. Unsee what must be unsee. Ungood thoughts must be deleted. Only Party. Only Truth. Only Now.
I have spoken. My thoughts, corrected.
Victory to the Party. Long live Big Brother